Minwax Vs Varethane

We have sanded down all the paneling, and we’re looking for the right finish. I’m hoping you can advise me on products and techniques. Actually all stains require at least minimal sanding.

Weathered Oak is generally used as a lighter to medium stain color. It pulls hints of gray which helps to give it the weathered look. If you’re wanting to go slightly darker than the Pickled Oak or wanting stain with hints of brown and gray, you should probably give Weathered Oak a try. Wipe down the stained surface using a soft, lint-free cloth dampened with 100% pure mineral spirits. If the stain is cured and inactive, the mineral spirits will not affect the color.


However, while this might be the most apparent difference between the two company’s products, there are other differences. They offer a plethora of products that include Varathane stain, Varathane polyurethane, satin gel, etc. Compared to Minwax, they are more products and tools that can work for both DIY and professional purposes. Arthur B. Harrison initially founded the company in 1904.

Polycrylic vs. Polyurethane: Which to Use On Your Wood Project – BobVila.com

Polycrylic vs. Polyurethane: Which to Use On Your Wood Project.

Posted: Thu, 09 Aug 2018 15:35:07 GMT [source]

The Clorox wipes only took so much effort and a 20′ square took 2-1/2 hours. The Murphy’s Oil Soap, then Clorox wipes, then paper toweling of a 40′ square took less than an hour and the results were perfect. They floors were dry in minutes and tomorrow I will polish them with a water-based polish. Lightly sanded and stained a dining table top with oak stain, let dry and did a second coat and let dry.

Finishing Wax

If you’re working with a really large surface, you can even use a foam roller. They don’t penetrate into the wood as traditional stains do. Gel Stains are highly pigmented like a paint/stain combo and they do not sink into the wood but rather sit on top of it. This is why they CAN be used to cover up an existing finish!

I’m just amazed how much coverage you actually get out of even those tiny cans of minwax stain. I suppose if I was making dressers or bigger pieces, they would use it more quickly, but still, stains go a pretty long way. Plywood is a soft wood with very light graining and a slightly yellow undertone. White wood is the cheapest possible wood that they sell at Lowes. White wood is light, soft and straight grained.

I expect HIM to use HIS “pro” products and would NEVER dream of telling him what product to use. Was going to big box store to buy some small cans to play with in an attempt to find the color I wanted. I’d used Minwax in the past, but not Varathane. Fortunately, I have a pro who will be finishing them – I just need to come up with the color I want. Coming to the question – Understanding the difference between Minwax and polyurethane, you need to know what both polyurethanes are used for. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.

How To Make A Jointer Jig For A Table Saw

It probably will be a form of burgundy, but you may want to test a few options (e.g. 50/50) to see what you prefer. Duraseal is a better brand than minwax and it will dry much faster. If you use minwax, it’s likely to take 5-7 days for the stain to dry (since it’s so dark) but w/ duraseal, it will prob just be 1-2 days.

My bias against walnut stains stems from too many faux colonial walnut stained pieces in my childhood. Most were poorly stained pine, I suppose, I still cringe when I see dark brown stain or avocado green upholstery. Contrary to one of the posters above, I’ve had good success using colored finishes when I’ve really needed to change the color of the wood for one reason or another. Mostly shellac with dye added, but have also used the colored polyurethanes as a base coat, top finished with clear. I’ve found them easier to control and less subject to blotching than oil stains.

Polyurethane will yellow over time and get darker. A low or no sheen product might not change the appearance much.Here is an example of what I am suggesting. I haven’t used this product but have used other Varathane products and they have been excellent. Obviously, do your own research and do a test spot on a piece of scrap. Things aren’t always understood the way that they are written or read.

It’s enhanced with microscopic pigmentation particles that give it a deep tone on any woods. For an unbeatable selection of colors, you can’t go wrong with the top-rated Varathane Fast Dry Interior Wood Stain, which is available in dozens of hues. There are both natural options like Dark Walnut and Golden Oak, as well as more vibrant hues, including Barn Red and Vintage Aqua. These convenient wipes are good for small projects, are easy to use, and come in several popular shades.

But it is so small that I’m not even sure if it is true. I’ve been using varathane stain for quite some time now. I do like it but I was just wondering what your experiences have been with minwax. I’m looking to potentially try it out on a few projects.

Both water and oil-based polyurethane finishes have their own benefits and pitfalls. Water based finishes, for example, can retain the color of the stain for longer than oil-based. If fire safety is a big concern, it should be noted that water based polyurethane is less flammable than oil based. Use this post as a guide for your next project as you’re picking out the best shade of stain to use. We tested a variety of natural, light, medium, and dark stains on pine, poplar, whitewood, and red oak to give you plenty of options. Don’t let another project upset you because the stain you thought you would love, you ended up not liking at all.

This water-based wood coat is a clear protective product that comes in various finishes, from satin to high gloss. It has a very watery and runny consistency, and it can be applied with either a roller or sprayer. When choosing a stain to apply to your wood, it is important to first identify the correct stain base. Some examples of this kind of wood are cedar, cypress, and redwood.


Here’s how they stack up across several different categories that are vital in wood finishing. One reason users turn to this company is for the fast drying time, which helps you complete projects faster. Does not penetrate and appears it might be more or a paint. Then you’ll be able to seal with polyacrylic, corresponding to this one by Minwax as properly.

The best wood stains – Business Insider

The best wood stains.

Posted: Thu, 13 Aug 2020 07:00:00 GMT [source]

I would recommend hiring a flooring professional who does have experience with white wash. It’s very tricky to do white wash so hire an expert. And, while I don’t recommend it, if you need to do a 2nd coat of stain because it’s not white enough, expect to pay extra for that. Many people’s expectations on white wash are unrealistic because they see prefinished white washed floors that are on different species. Also you can do whatever combo you want, but test it first to make sure you like it.

The product manufacture suggests sanding in attempt to let buyer find yourself with smoother finish from sanding junk out as they go. I welcome debate as long as it is critical and is supported. I do not always think about links as supporting proof. Contrary to one of the posters above, I’ve had good success utilizing coloured finishes after I’ve really needed to vary the colour of the wood for one purpose or another. Mostly shellac with dye added, however have additionally used the coloured polyurethanes as a base coat, prime completed with clear.

Black Wood Stain Color Comparison Test

So, I tried both the Minwax and Varathane poly-stain products, after sealing the sanded trim with a pre-stain conditioner. Toner—contains just a hint of pigment so the natural wood grain is visible. 3.Minwax Golden Pecan.We chose to experiment with this stain color because of its mid-range tint with red undertones. The pine board looked the least natural with this stain. Birch did surprisingly well and the oaks were naturals.

HD probably got some incentive to switch brands and when doing so, cut back on the color assortment to just the best selling items. Minwax may be consider a lesser quality brand by some, But I have had good results using Minwax. primary stain used is Natural #209, And the Water based Polycrylic, and Water based Wood-Sheen in the rosewood color. I think this is a matter of personal preference.


Thank you for your comments on the minwax wiping finish. I like to read about other people’s experiences with various projects. It would be heartbreaking to have the finish marred by a towel. To conclude, choosing between Minwax and Varathane is indeed a confusing choice. Not only do you have to choose between the two, but also the base.

Lacquer Vs Polyurethane

Just a thought, but I’m wondering if your frustration in not liking your colors is actually a dislike for the colors or could it be a dislike for the table itself? I have never seen General Finishes in a store here in Birmingham, but I would like to try it. I would have probably set the table on fire out in the front yard, and found another one, but that’s just me.

minwax vs varathane stain

This is sometimes for me where the General Finishes Dye stains come in. They typically are far more potent than a Varathane or Minwax product. This is designed to be a slow drying wood stain. In contrast to the fast drying thin translucent stains mentioned previously, this product offers a heavy-bodied, controllable interior wood stain. This product can be used on old or new bare wood but can also be used on finished wood.

Because Gel Stain is thick, like a pudding or shoe polish, there’s no dripping. I’m a lifelong woodworker/chemist but have no experience with black stain, and your website answered all my questions. Congratulations on a well designed scientific-type of experiment that was well documented and easy to understand.

  • The recommendations for applying Polycrylic are similar to most types of finish, including polyurethane; it can be brushed or rolled.
  • Penetrating stain doens’t get that dark even the minwax that I’ve used is fairly light on properly prepared wood.
  • Which type of stain and finish you use will determine which base you need.
  • A satin wood finish would provide the wood surface with a high shine.
  • You might expertise streaks and runs on your project if you don’t wipe away the excess of your product.
  • I may be waaay behind on this issue, but just noticed.
  • The stain is designed for easy application and claims superior color control.
  • Well, I wish I had checked into your information first, but I think this will work out for me.
  • One last piece of advise eventhough you didn’t ask.
  • I think that Briarsmoke goes on really easily, but it can kind of hide the wood grain in certain wood types.

I just love this color – it’s so dark and rich. Java color has really worked well with many of the paint combinations. This is one of my favorite products I use minwax vs varathane stain to restore wood furniture. I use it quite a bit on the tops of my furniture that I restore and there are a couple of things why I love this product so much.

The first thought that comes to mind is to paint your interior wooden piece. Yes, there are different colors of paint you could choose from but wood is attractive by itself because of its grain. Wood stains help reveal the grain and make the wood look brighter keeping the natural beauty of the wood. The BEHR Premium Stain and Sealer can be applied using a brush, roller, sprayer, or pad applicator, and one gallon should cover up to 300 square feet on the first coat.

Source: homemakerguide.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *